Big Spoon Roasters Handcrafted Mini Nut Butter Sampler, Set of 4

You butter believe it.

Our love for these nut butters could fill a book—but in a nutshell? They’re handmade to order in North Carolina, so they come fresher than fresh. Then there’s the ingredients, straight from producers who live and breathe top-notch quality and sustainability. (Think: fresh-roasted peanuts, flavor-packed Mission almonds, organic wildflower honey, and Vermont maple syrup—no palm oil in sight.)